Skip to content

Mass Scale: Test data

The measurements behind the paper’s Section 3, as published on the OSF project (Tests/, Logs/ and the plots in Documentation/). Section 2.6 of the paper describes the procedures.

PuTTY captures of the scale’s serial output, kept byte for byte (they mix CRLF and bare CR line endings). Each begins with the scale’s start-up messages and the sensitivity read from EEPROM, then the weight reports.

File Capture Test
200623 - 100g.log 2020-06-23 standard masses, 1 g to 100 g, on the 100 g TAL221
200623 - 500g.log 2020-06-23 standard masses on the 500 g TAL221
200623 - 5000g.log 2020-06-23 standard masses on the 5 kg TAL220
200624 - 5000g (PLA).log 2020-06-24 the 5 kg TAL220 in the printed PLA housing
200624 - 5000g (wood).log 2020-06-24 the 5 kg TAL220 on a pine frame, for comparison with the housing
20200121.log 2020-01-21 an earlier session, with the firmware before the SMA serial interface
20200221.log 2020-02-21 an earlier session; the spreadsheet’s comparison sheets carry the same date

The standard-mass captures are the “second set of tests” in the paper, logged at 1 Hz in continuous-report mode (<R>) with a 10-value sliding average, each mass left on the bed for about 30 s, after an hour’s warm-up.

Balance Shootout.xlsx (last changed 2020-06-24) holds the processed data, one sheet per test: the standard-mass tests above (200623 - 100g Standard Mass, 200623 - 500g Standard Mass, 200623 - 5000g Standards PLA, 200624 - 5000g Standards Wood, and 200624 - 5000g Standards PL (2) for 200624 - 5000g (PLA).log), the comparisons against the Denver A-160 analytical balance (200221 - 5000g vs A-160 LC1, 200221 - 500g vs A-160 LC1 and LC2, 200323 - 500g vs A-160), the self-calibration of the 100 g cell against the 500 g cell (200414 - 100g vs WAOAW and 500g), 200121, and Sheet1, a priced list of the electronic components and load-cell hardware.

plots/ holds the six figures of the comparison tests (2020-04-15): for each load cell, the standard deviation of five repeated readings at each mass (* Std.png) and the absolute difference from the reference balance (* Avg Diff.png): the quantities the paper plots in Figures 10 to 12.

Load cell Files Result in the paper
5 kg TAL220 5kg Std.png, 5kg Avg Diff.png sigma 0.0163 g on average, 0.0363 g from the A-160
500 g TAL221 500g Std.png, 500g Avg Diff.png sigma 0.0207 g, 0.0142 g from the A-160
100 g TAL221 100g Std.png, 100g Avg Diff.png sigma 0.005 g, 0.0198 g from the 500 g TAL221 it was calibrated against